You are currently viewing What Does America’s First Muslim Senator Mean?

What Does America’s First Muslim Senator Mean?

  • Post published:

By Aly Kamadia, Editor-in-Chief of iDose Magazine

What does it mean that the first Muslim American senator has been elected?

Before addressing that question (as much as one can in a newsletter), we must highlight that the Republican Party got absolutely decimated in the midterms roughly two weeks ago. One can feel the heat from some Republicans’ boiling blood over Democratic victories they’d dismiss as “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion”:

The first Native American woman elected to the US Senate, and the first Native American woman elected governor of any state; the first openly gay man elected to the Senate; the first Black woman elected governor of any US state. And of course, Abdul El-Sayed becoming the first Muslim elected to the Senate in American history.

What to make of El-Sayed?

It’s far too early to tell, but there are at least three reasons his victory is highly symbolic to many Muslims (and those who believe in diversity).

To begin with, El-Sayed’s victory is a slap in the face to the many bigots who practice and promote Islamophobia and hatred towards Muslims. To be sure, there is all sorts of bigotry that extends beyond Islamophobia—antisemitism, to offer a timely example.

But Muslims seem to hold a special place in the American bigot’s heart. El-Sayed’s victory is symbolic within this context because it shows a contemporary America where such hatred may be slowly fading.

Next, El-Sayed chose not to follow “strategic” advice about “changing his tone” (a glaring euphemism) vis-à-vis Israel. That a state of roughly 10 million people (Michigan) elected him anyway is no minor fact.

After all, El-Sayed publicly condemns Israel for prosecuting a genocide.

El-Sayed publicly condemns Israel for being an apartheid state.

El-Sayed publicly condemns billions of American tax dollars spent financing needless wars abroad that kill thousands of children, rather than fixing an American state (i.e., Michigan) and country whose economy is incapable of serving its citizens—who would much rather have tax dollars serving their needs.

Indeed, the reality of a potential Muslim US Senator who was talking openly about Israel’s crimes drew in the notorious pro-Israel lobbying organization AIPAC. According to some reports, it spent more than $40,000,000 trying to knock out El-Sayed.

And he still won.

Perhaps I’m old school, but there’s something admirable and very symbolic about a person who refuses to be a coward. (Of note is also the drastic shift in American opinion towards Israel.)

Finally, El-Sayed’s victory is telling because it reflects the emotions of the majority of American voters: they are very pissed off—to put the matter ever so eloquently.

Economic justice becomes nothing but a fairy tale when citizens can’t afford health care or groceries while they watch CEOs of trillion-dollar companies on the news, at least one of whom was doing much more than flirting with a potential Chinese intelligence asset.

Not only are Americans’ pockets empty, but thanks not least to the neoliberal policies of the past few decades, their money has been transferred to the superrich.

That is a notable part of the reason America went from its first African American president to a billionaire and fraud preaching populism in 2016.

It is also why we are seeing protests in many countries as life becomes increasingly unaffordable.

How long can such a situation remain tenable?

What comes next?

That remains an open question, and one we will keep our eyes on. iDose Magazine has been posting intellectual commentary on the election before and after it. Most recently, we published a piece by the provocative, world-renowned philosopher Slavoj Žižek, titled “Why Trump and MAGA’s Midterm Defeat Won’t Change History.”

I may not agree with some of Žižek’s opinions. Indeed, there are a number of opinions expressed by authors on iDose that I disagree with. But that is the nature of intellectual pluralism and free speech, both of which remain core to our identity.

November 18th, 2026

Aly Kamadia is Editor-in-Chief of iDose Magazine. He is also Director of Kamadia & Associates. He holds a BA and MA in Political Science, both from the University of Waterloo (Canada).

© All Rights Reserved